Mudaliar Committee, officially known as Health Survey and Planning Committee, was appointed by Government of India in 1959 and submitted its influential report in 1962.
Headed by Dr. A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar, then Vice-Chancellor of Madras University, committee was tasked with evaluating progress of India’s health sector since landmark Bhore Committee report (1946) and first two Five-Year Plans.
1. Objectives of Committee
Primary mission of Mudaliar Committee was a mid correction for India’s healthcare trajectory. Its goals included:
-
Assessment: Evaluating medical relief and public health progress achieved after Bhore Committee’s recommendations.
-
Review: Assessing implementation of health projects during First and Second Five-Year Plans.
-
Planning: Formulating recommendations for future health development and expansion of health services.
2. Key Observations
Upon review, committee found several gaps in existing system:
-
Quality Issues: While number of Primary Health Centres (PHCs) had grown, quality of services provided was often unsatisfactory due to lack of staff and infrastructure.
-
Infrastructure Shortfalls: Expansion of medical facilities had not met ambitious standards set by Bhore Committee.
-
Disease Burden: Communicable diseases like malaria, smallpox, and tuberculosis remained significant threats, and life expectancy was still relatively low.
3. Major Recommendations
Mudaliar Committee shifted focus from rapid expansion to consolidation and quality improvement.
Strengthening the Infrastructure
-
PHC Population Norms: It recommended that a Primary Health Centre should not cater to more than 40,000 people.
-
Strengthening Existing Units: Committee advised against opening new PHCs until existing ones were fully staffed and equipped.
-
District Hospitals: It emphasized that District Hospitals should be strengthened with specialist services to function as effective referral centers.
Administrative Reforms
-
All India Health Service: One of its most famous proposals was creation of an All India Health Service, modeled after Indian Administrative Service (IAS), to bring professional leadership to health management.
-
Integration of Services: It reiterated need to integrate curative and preventive services at all administrative levels.
-
Regional Level: It suggested a regional administrative layer between State headquarters and District level to supervise 2–3 districts.
Medical Education and Manpower
-
Doctor-Population Ratio: It suggested an initial target of 1 doctor per 3,000 population.
-
Medical Colleges: Committee advocated for establishing one medical college for every 5 million (50 lakh) people.
-
Specialist Training: It recommended major changes in medical education, including a three-month training period in preventive and social medicine to create social physicians.
4. Historical Significance
Mudaliar Committee is regarded as bridge between foundational dream of Bhore Committee and practical realities of independent India. By emphasizing strengthening of District Hospital as a specialist hub, it helped shape referral system that exists in India today.
Comparison at a Glance
| Feature | Bhore Committee (1946) | Mudaliar Committee (1962) |
| Focus | Initial development and expansion | Consolidation and planning |
| PHC Norms | 1 PHC per 10,000–20,000 people | 1 PHC per 40,000 people |
| Key Emphasis | Integration of preventive/curative | Strengthening referral (District) hospitals |
| Service Goal | “3 Million Plan” (long-term) | All India Health Service creation |